Angelina's Restaurant Yelp Reviews - Angelina's Restaurant - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Angelina's Restaurant for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Angelina's Restaurant from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
Staten Island's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Angelina's Restaurant
Angelina's Restaurant Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
38 Reviews
0 Replys |
Was there for an engagement party, well set up, pretty
Was there for an engagement party, well set up, pretty cool staff service good glasses kept full, apps were delicious and hot, bread was good I was impressed considering it was a catered event...
Be the first to ReplyI'm here for the brunch party as I write this I see every
I'm here for the brunch party as I write this I see every flag being put out but the Israeli flag is no where to be seen even when I asked for it, also asked the to play telaviv and they did cut it out in less than a minute the only reason they entertained the notion of putting in on is because people at my table come here all the time and spend a lot of money.....antisemites!!!!
Be the first to ReplyThe ambiance and candle lit dinner was super romantic, I
The ambiance and candle lit dinner was super romantic, I loved the live music and the staff. The pasta was very good and high quality, perhaps the best gnocchi I've had. Unfortunately the meat was average and the seafood was subpar. The filet mignon wasn't anything special it tasted similar to cheaper restaurants, I got the branzino and it says it is deboned but there were so many bones I could barely take an incautious bite. The fish was flavorless and came with a side of I what tasted like the frozen veggies you get at a supermarket. Don't get me wrong the atmosphere the music it is such a romantic ambiance and I had a lot of fun. For this price level I would expect more satisfying protein options. I've been to many other restaurants in this price range that offer better tasting foods, you do pay for the amazing staff and the atmosphere. The host even gave my partner a rose discreetly for him to give me which make our night even more romantic.
Be the first to ReplyI cam here to attend a event .
All I have to say is this restaurant and venue was gorgeous. I absolutely loved it. Everyone was very nice and introduced themselves. My friend and I explained that we're were here attending a event and they were able that we came in to grab some food before attending out event. The food was very delicious and it tasted very fresh. The prices were also amazing too. The views are out this world. I absolutely loved the views and seeing the most beautiful sunset going down . I would highly recommend anyone coming here you will not be disappointed.
Be the first to ReplyI went to the best wedding ever at Angelina's.
The hour and a half cocktail hour was beautifully decorated, a gorgeous sunset on the water and had several delicious food stations including an awesome seafood bar. The staff did an excellent job the whole night. Very happy with everything they did, it was great.
Be the first to ReplyCelebrating our 41st wedding anniversary today and we had
Celebrating our 41st wedding anniversary today and we had fabulous service- delicious food- fantastic service!
Be the first to ReplyWas there for lunch yesterday.
Appetizers tasted OK, but were small portions, and the prices were astronomical. My main course, frutta di mare, had one scallop, three mussels and 5 tiny vongole. The menu said jumbo shrimp, but the three shrimp in the dish were the size of a dime. Basically, I paid $42 for a dish of pasta. On top of that, there was a large piece of sharp metal in the bread pudding. Good thing I felt it in my mouth before chewing. I didn't say anything; I just wanted to get out of there. There are many, many better places in Staten Island. I think they feel they have a name, and they don't have to try so hard. Never again.
Be the first to ReplyThe food was delicious and the portion was enough.
The service and atmosphere was great.
Be the first to ReplyHad dinner there last night,everything has changed
Had dinner there last night,everything has changed there,all tents and buildings left right all over no more views walls everywhere,not the same!Food was excellent,staff not friendly at all,very surprised!its now a party hall,sad not happy sorry Angelinas
Be the first to ReplyFood is good with a nice atmosphere but ridiculously
Food is good with a nice atmosphere but ridiculously overpriced with small portions. We left hungry.
Be the first to ReplyMe and my boyfriend came here for celebration.
Beautiful restaurant and atmosphere is good. However, the service is awful!! We had the reservation and still had to wait one hour because they are letting other people (they are after us) to have the tables. I believe they are racism to us. Definitely not recommend this restaurant.
Be the first to ReplyMangiare-Delizioso Servizio-Impeccabile Ambiance-warm,
Mangiare-Delizioso Servizio-Impeccabile Ambiance-warm, inviting, sexy, festiveAlways a great meal, a great drink and fabulous music!
Be the first to ReplyWe were very underwhelmed by this place.
I got a gift card so we figured we would come for a nice meal. The ambience is definitely beautiful but that's it. 1-It started when they asked if we wanted sparkling water and I said " no just tap" it came in a bottle so I assumed they use nice bottles for the table and put tap water in it. Well there was $9 added to the bill for still water. 2- portion sizes are tiny! 3- my dish was mushy eggplant with pasta. 4- kept pushing the wine (I guess they made up for it with the still water)Will not be returning... overpriced and you get nothing if you don't order drinks!
Be the first to ReplyService is horrible.
Waiters and wait staff speak little to no English. We had to remind them on multiple occasions to bring us what we ordered. Also brought us the wrong appetizers and took us a few attempts to convince them that they were the wrong appetizers until they finally agreed with us. Food is ok but certainly not worth the crazy prices. $199 for a tomahawk steak for 2!! $70 for a small piece of filet mignon with a side of potatoes that you could eat in one bite!! Crazy. Would never go back.
Be the first to ReplyWent here for new years eve, the place was popping with a
Went here for new years eve, the place was popping with a live singer and DJ. They went all out spraying liquid nitrogen to create a dry ice effect on the dance floor. Overall, it was a bit expensive and the portions were small, but somewhat tasty. The best dish was the carpaccio by far with the truffle oil and arugula. The pasta was nothing special, needed a little more seasoning or for the meat to be sautéed. The rack of lamb was so so small for a half rack. It could have used more mushrooms also, but mainly the size was the issue. They might have been new Zealand lamb chops given the size. Come here for the atmosphere over the food. The food is a bit of an afterthought.
Be the first to ReplyI was there 8:45 with reservations at 9pm.
The servers asked us to wait on the side. All people after me got the table and after couple of time inquiry. They ridiculous just put us as arrival at 9:25 pm in the system and asked us to continue to wait. We end up canceling the table. Try to avoid this place.
Be the first to ReplyAlthough the food was good it's quickly ruined by the
Although the food was good it's quickly ruined by the ambiance and the service. We were sat in the middle of a door way. I don't mind it being loud, people are having a good time the restaurant cannot control that. However, I do mind being sat in the middle of a doorway where no less than 3 waiters were standing at any given time. Sometimes as many as 9 were crowding essentially standing over our table. It's hard to have a conversation when their conversation rules over the voice of your dinner date. It's a shame that they over crowd the dinning room. They could have eliminated where they sat us even if it means loosing $1,000 a night just to deliver their guest the best experience
Be the first to ReplyI had a very nice evening.
Food was excellent, atmosphere and ambiance, great. Service was good up until the end. My bill was $160. I left a $30 tip on that which is just under 20%. My waiter didn't even have the decency to come over and say thank you after i paid the bill. I had to coax it out of him. That sort of annoyed me. $18 for one glass of sangria is way out of line too. I went in there knowing full well that it is probably the most expensive restaurant on the island. The only reason I was in there is because I won a $50 gift card the week before. No way in hell would I spend $190 to dine ANYWHERE. Not even if I was trying to impress anyone. She has a very classy and elegant place though. I am sure it attracts a higher class of people. Sorry, I work way too hard for my money to spend it like that.
Be the first to ReplyWe went here over the weekend for a celebration.
We had wanted to try Angelina's for a while, but should have read the reviews beforehand. The manager was friendly when we sat down and congratulated us. Shortly after, it went down hill from there. The service was absolutely terrible. For a "fancy" restaurant, this was a huge disappointment. We sat for over ten minutes before a waiter came over and asked if we were finally ready. We stated that we had not received any food or drink menus yet. After ordering it took a long time for us to get any water or bread. The place seemed to be unorganized and quite a mess. One of the waiters was yelling at another waitress and snapping his fingers at her. For an "upscale" place that is not the type of vibe you want to be around. Most of our dishes were pretty good. One pasta dish was overcooked. The portions here are very small. For the price you are paying it is not worth it. Whenever we pick a nice place to celebrate, we never get such a negative experience such as this. There are SO many other restaurants on Staten Island where you can have a nice meal and this place is not worth anyone's time. Please read the reviews before you make a mistake.
Be the first to ReplyLet me start off by saying Angelina's has never
Let me start off by saying Angelina's has never disappointed me until my most recent time being there . A group of us went this Sunday for bottomless brunch. Seeing the posts on instagram this brunch looked amazing. First, we get there at 12:00pm, only to wait almost 40 minutes to be seated. We went to the upstairs room which was so dark you could hardly see. They covered all the windows with torn pieces of black tablecloths. Next, the croissants and bagels on the table were cold and not fresh. Finally, we ask for martinis and they were served in plastic cups . Isn't this Angelina's ? The food comes out , it was cold and barely edible. WHAT A DISAPPOINTMENT. For $150 plus tax per person I would expect a bit better. The music was great, just wish there was actual room to dance. Nothing like bringing 9 other ladies to this place, talking it up to have incredible food, and then leave starving and having to go get food somewhere else.
Be the first to ReplyAbsolutely disgusting.
After crunching on sand in a scallop in a $60 entree I returned my dinner selection to the kitchen. With a promise to "tell the manager" never fulfilled, the entree appeared on our bill. No offer of a complimentary coffee or dessert for a meal not eaten. Nothing.Finally I challenged the staff with a poor review for their neglect. Suddenly it was removed from the bill. Look, we all know our NYC restaurants are hurting post pandemic crap, but if you value your patrons they will reward you tenfold.Not tonight.
Be the first to ReplyWent back again.
Ordered more and different food and I have to say, was phenomenal. Much more flavorful. Sat in their indoor tent and it was absolutely stunning. 4 hours went by in the blink of an eye. Ended with their amazing tiramisu and
Be the first to ReplyStay away unless you want to pay for chef boy ardeeee (I
Stay away unless you want to pay for chef boy ardeeee (I wish this was a lie). Oh and if you want to melt in 90 degree weather without ax
Be the first to ReplyParking line is ridiculous I do recommend to go to this
Parking line is ridiculous I do recommend to go to this place a lot of good place on the island skip that place because you have to walk to the restaurant for 25 minutes
Be the first to ReplyThink Staten Island mob wives meetings housewives of NJ
Think Staten Island mob wives meetings housewives of NJ meets wanna-be high end restaurant in Manhattan overlooking dirty jerz! Expensive, overpriced for just ok food and the view is of Perth Amboy sooo yeah.
Be the first to Reply