Cosimo's Woodbury Yelp Reviews - Cosimo's Woodbury - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Cosimo's Woodbury for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Cosimo's Woodbury from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
Woodbury's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Cosimo's Woodbury
Cosimo's Woodbury Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
30 Reviews
0 Replys |
food here for me was terrible service, was also bad my
food here for me was terrible service, was also bad my kids mother probably got a lot of drinks in her while waiting for my other food came back terrible she went back they made another one it was terrible she told me while burping they are giving me the pizza for free I will be credited for the mishap days went by til this day never seen the credit back to my card it's a great location as im driving home every day ambiance, never got to chance to experience it not sure if I even want too......................................................:::.
Be the first to ReplyBeen here a few times when we hit the outlet mall.
Food quality has been consistently good. Our favorite is their portobello mushroom pizza. It come with mushrooms and grilled red peppers and lots of cheese. Excellent when eaten piping hot. Another favorite is their fried calamari. The pasta is good too.
Be the first to ReplyBeen going to this location since 2011 two or three times a
Been going to this location since 2011 two or three times a year. It's a perfect meeting place for Fort Lee NJ and Woodstock NY. We love it here. None of us have ever included a trip to Woodbury to shop. It's all about seeing each other and feasting. The fried calamari ($17) with an extra serving of their pomodoro sauce ($3) is delectable. Perfect for 3 people. I frequently order a side dish or two as my entree. I love them all. Last week I shared the snapper ($28) with polenta and Brussel sprouts that was fabulous. I took most of my share home and happily devoured it. My friend ate her share there. My other friend ordered the eggplant parm ($20) and adored it and also took some home. We shared the apple pizzete with cinnamon ice cream ($10). First time after all these years I tried that and IT'S A WINNER. Get it! Delightful staff. We'll be back in Feb or March for birthdays if I can't convince the group to go again before that.
Be the first to ReplyGood food.
Not amazing but not terrible. I feel like the chicken is rubbery a lot of the time
Be the first to ReplyOmg the food is finger-licking good! We sadly skipped the
Omg the food is finger-licking good! We sadly skipped the appetizers and headed straight for the entrees. We ordered the Herb Baked Shrimp (with wild rice) and the Formaggi pizza. For drinks we ordered Pomango Twist () and the Cosimo Punch. The first bite of food was the pizza... and the first words were "oh my... so good." It was an explosion of flavor in my mouth. The herb shrimp was so savory and the kale was amazing!!!! We were stuffed with all the meals, we didn't even get to order dessert. However, we did order more meals to go. We had the Shrimp Risotto and the Woodfire Snapper. Both meals were great for a very late 'snack' and early meal, lol. Lastly, the service was awesome. The waitress, I believe her name was Julie (sorry if it isn't) was very friendly, kind, and patient. Do I recommend this place, umm YES. We are already planning on taking a trip up north again to visit.
Be the first to ReplyThe place is clean, staff pleasant and food good.
They had GF options and I didn't get sick.Fair prices. Would go back.
Be the first to ReplyHave been going here for years.
Was really disgusted tonight. Ordered a simple meal chicken Francese and seafood fra diavolo. My dinner came out....waitress forgot to put the entire order in. So my meal comes but she forgot to put the seafood fra diavolo in! What??? How do you put 1/2 the order in. So our waitress apologizes and the manager offered to make me a new meal so we could eat together... that's the whole idea right?? The meal comes out the seafood fra diavolo is good, my chicken francese is good have a few bites and see a red blood line. I'm immediately turned off- it's quite red. The waitress never bothered to come back to check if our meals are ok. I told her my chicken is not cooked and she comes out that the food was cooked although a big red blood line through the chicken. Instead of offering to remove the 27.00 meal from my check she offers a $5.00 dessert. I'm terribly disappointed in the service tonight. I rarely write reviews but after the horrendous meal and service I had to. My husband and I have gone here weekly and after 2 bad meals and service in a row. It's going to be a long time till we return.
Be the first to ReplyGreat food with amazing flavor, great atmosphere with
Great food with amazing flavor, great atmosphere with spacious seating, and a great staff that is very friendly to top it off. This was our first time here and the service was great. Food portions are great for adults and kids! Truly enjoyed our evening here and will certainly come again in the future.
Be the first to ReplyCame across Cosimos on a recommendation from a colleague,
Came across Cosimos on a recommendation from a colleague, and boy was it an excellent idea. Our waitress was amazing very on point with getting our drinks, apps, entrees and dessert all correct! I We started with a glass of wine, ordered the family style antipasto, for our entrees we had seafood pasta and 8hour roasted pork with mashed potatoes, so much food I took some to go! Desert the crème brûlée was just perfect! I will most definitely be returning to try more items on the menu.
Be the first to ReplyThe staff is super friendly, food and drinks are delicious.
The atmosphere is casual and fun. The bar is great and always full.
Be the first to ReplyStopped in for a late dinner after shopping at the nearby
Stopped in for a late dinner after shopping at the nearby outlet mall. We had a small ceaser salad, meatball pizza, and creme brulee for dessert. Everything was delicious. It came out quickly too which was a bonus with 2 more hours left to get home to Saratoga. Easily some of the best pizza we've ever had. The meatballs were super flavorful, crust was good, sauce was great, and the herbed ricotta really just set off the entire thing. Even the salad was well executed; the lettuce was slightly sweet and crunchy, dressing was really good, and I think the croutons were homemade. Glad we decided to stop in and will stop in again when we are in this area!
Be the first to ReplyOlive bread was delicious, first time having it, what a fun
Olive bread was delicious, first time having it, what a fun little appetizer.House salad I got with the honey balsamic vinaigrette, the dressing was gross.Ordered la grigliata pizza without cheese. Their crust is super yummy.Also broccoli garlic pizza without the cheese and whole wheat crust. Unfortunately they won't substitute any other toppings for it so it was super plain. Would recommend flexibility in substituting in their toppings if people don't eat cheese instead of having to order a really expensive custom pizza.Parents ordered the kale beet salad, they thought all the flavors worked well together.Herb baked shrimp they didn't like.White clam sauce linguini pasta they thought was okay.This place seems to be a hit or miss. Again, we like that it's not salty but could be a lot better.
Be the first to ReplyAfter a visit to Woodbury Commons, we came here and had a
After a visit to Woodbury Commons, we came here and had a good meal and good wine. Very nice place to hang out, eat and drink in the afternoon. Nice both indoor and outdoor.
Be the first to ReplyDefinitely one of my favorite spots.
I'm hard to please and every time I visit I leave not only full but satisfied.
Be the first to ReplyStopped for dinner on Tuesday evening.
Fresh bread served to table was great! Served with EVOO, yummy! Sadly my entree was pasta with bits of chewy eggplant. The cook on duty did not prepare the eggplant properly and was a huge disappointment. Won't be returning here.
Be the first to Reply3.5 / 5.0 - We came here for an early lunch before an
3.5 / 5.0 - We came here for an early lunch before an afternoon of outlet shopping at Woodbury Commons. The restaurant was spacious with high ceilings and our server was very attentive, but the food was subpar.We ordered the following for 2 to share:- Toscano Pear Salad ($14+)The salad was nice, with arugula, pear, pecorino toscano and prosecco vinaigrette. It had a little too much dressing for our taste, though, and we should have asked for it on the side.- Mozzarella Fresca Pizza ($16+)This wood fired pizza was underwhelming. The ratio of the ingredients was unbalanced and the pizza completely fell apart as we were trying to eat it. The crust wasn't great, but perhaps, the Margherita would have been better.
Be the first to ReplyGreat food! Good service.
When ever I go to Woodbury commons, I have to stop at Cosimo's!
Be the first to ReplyAmazing food.
Ordered the Ravioli from the daily specials. Definitely the best Ravioli I've ever had. Hopefully they have it again on my next visit.
Be the first to ReplyMy favorite local restaurant for dining in and take-out!
My favorite local restaurant for dining in and take-out! Great service, and delicious food options! I have also used for several catered events at my home, the guests were raving about the food!
Be the first to ReplyWhenever we're in town, we always order extra garlic bread
Whenever we're in town, we always order extra garlic bread with cheese and without. It is quite addicting because the flavors just keep having you crave and want for more! Their Truffle Portobello flatbread is quite yummy; the mushrooms are soft and tender and with the Parmigiano cheese, it completes the flatbread. Their calamari is very good as well as their Cesar salad. I always get their pizzas; I try to be a little adventurous but I just can't get myself to miss out on their pizza. Give this place a try! You will not be disappointed!
Be the first to ReplyWe had a party of 6 and was seating really quickly since
We had a party of 6 and was seating really quickly since there's a lot of seating at this restaurant. Our waiter was kinda awkward and didn't really introduce himself or anything when he arrived at our table. They did give complimentary bread for the table with olive & oil dipping. For appetizers we ordered the fried calamari and the waffle potatoes with gorgonzola. The calamari was fried really well and had a good portion to share for 6 people. The cheese waffle fries had rosemary and a cheese sauce that made it super creamy and delicious, especially as the fries were fried crunchy. I really enjoyed both appetizers.For pizzas, we ordered Nick's pizza and the Spicy Fennel Sausage with sausage added. Nick's pizza was more of a margarita pizza style with a lot of cheese, while the Spicy Fennel Sausage pizza was marinara based and the sausage made it a little spicy as well. I would say that the Spicy Fennel Sausage pizza didn't hold up as well compared to Nick's pizza and it was more messy. But the cheese pulls for both pizzas were amazing. They also provided extra parmesan cheese and pepper seasoning to add yourself. Keep in mind that the pizzas are cut into 4's, so I would advise to tell the waiter ahead of time if you need it cut into 6 pieces or another amount. Two pizzas to share for 6 people was a perfect amount and we were all pretty full afterwards.
Be the first to ReplyWhen we first arrived, on an early Friday afternoon, they
When we first arrived, on an early Friday afternoon, they wanted to seat us in the very dark and extremely noisy bar area, but I asked for the brighter dining room that was only about 1/4 occupied. After being led to the very first booth behind the hostess desk, we then asked to be seated next to the bright window at a table that was half cushioned bench seats against the wall and the other side of the table were chairs. I need a firm chair to be comfortable so that worked out well for us. The atmosphere was nice, with extremely tall ceilings, sliding glass doors on 1 side, and music playing in the background - not too noisy, but just loud enough that we could tell what song was playing.The rest is all 5 star! Our waitress, Kelly, could not be friendlier! Very helpful, with a great sense of humor. The food was delicious and hit the spot. I got the prosciutto and fig flatbread minus the prosciutto, and also the kale and beet salad. I ate half of each there, and brought the rest home for a yummy dinner! My husband got the hamburger with Tuscan fries and enjoyed it very much. He had been there before for work lunches and knew what he liked there.I would definitely return when we are in the area. Next time I will ask for a specific seating area right away, now that I know the place.
Be the first to ReplyWon't blame the restaurant for the food arriving cold but
Won't blame the restaurant for the food arriving cold but it did. The pizzas were really good but the cheese that tasted like bleu cheese on the formaggi was bad. The creamy polenta was not creamy but tough. The calamari was delicious and so was the spinach and bacon pizza.
Be the first to ReplyCame here during the holidays and found cosimo's which was
Came here during the holidays and found cosimo's which was very close to Woodbury Commons outlet mall. Being that I've never been there before I didn't know what to expect. Let's just say I was pleasantly impressed and surprised! Everyone working had there masks on for everyone's safety, and the service was very thorough! I order the Lemon chicken & pasta, My expectations were exceeded! The flavors were exquisite and the lemon butter in the pasta bursting with flavor so I'd strongly recommend trying cosimo's!
Be the first to Replysolid, reliable high quality Italian/Pizza.
Stopped in here with a large group and was warmly received. service was very good
Be the first to Reply