Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City Tripadvisor Reviews - Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
Atlantic City's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City
Old Homestead Steak House Atlantic City Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
30 Reviews
0 Replys |
Where's the Beef? Old Homestead!!! :)
☆☆☆☆Omg! I'm a foody and appreciative of good food, service, and ambiance. Bing~bang, Old Homestead, covers all three, lol. The Prime Rib was a little well done but tasty. The broccoli rabbe was tough but garlicky flavorful. The spinach sautéed was quite delicious, and the warm walnut raisin complementary buns were nice. The star☆ of the experience was the strawberry shortcake 🍰. Pam, our server, was busy and attentive. Did an awesome job! Kudos, thank you. I will recommend and will be back to check out more delicious cuisine on the menu. 😊 2/26/2024
Be the first to ReplyNot our best Valentines Day dinner
My husband arranged a surprise trip to AC for Valentines Day which started with dinner at the Old Homestead. The food and service were beyond great but… we were seated at the absolute worst table in the place. To my right and within my reach was the area where dirty dishes were placed for later pick-up. Also, the flatware drawer was right next to me and the traffic in and out of the area made for much distraction resulting in a terrible experience.
Be the first to ReplyOld Homestead : Food and service was excellent
Food and service was excellent. Made reservation online which was very simple and efficient. Dinner was well worth the $$. Thursday in Jan still had a decent crowd.
Be the first to ReplyI REALLY miss Bobby Flays!
We have always had a good experience in the past coming to Old Homestead. Our last visit was a little disappointing as we had reservations well in advanced but had to wait over 30 minutes to be seated. Then we were seated in the hallway right next to the bar? It was obvious that there seats were added and left little room for anyone walking down the aisle. Service was fine and the food was OK... Going to try the new B Prime or one of the other AC Steak houses to find a new favorite!
Be the first to ReplyDinner before Sienfield
This old reliable restaurant did not disappoint. The special veal chop was cooked to perfection. The broccoli rabe was excellent. Our servers Micheal and Gladys were wonderful. They made our experience so much better. It was a fabulous way to celebrate
Be the first to ReplyAwful experience
Awful experience my wife and I both got food poisoning and it is impossible to speak with anyone at the restaurant. Very disappointing
Be the first to ReplyNot Good
Recently dined at Old Homestead for business and it was disappointing , especially since I have dined there before and always enjoyed it . The service was good and the drinks were good , the food was not , our porterhouse was overcooked and bland , the mashed potatoes didn't taste much better than boxed potatoes and the asparagus with hollandaise was nasty . For the price you pay , the kitchen needs to do a better job of making sure the food they send out is much better ... will not return .
Be the first to ReplyTraditional Steakhouse Delivering What You Expect
The food was excellent and initially, our service was great. But after the food came, it was hard to get service or the attention we needed. For example, we asked for a sauce that never came. Also, their salads are massive and serve two people; we recommend you be aware of this - which we weren't and over-ordered as we each got our own salad.
Be the first to ReplyHorrible experience
I have been coming here for years and last night was a complete disappointment from the host (Brian P) to the serving staff to the filets. We arrived at 8:25 for r 8:30 reservation. Wasn’t seated until around 8:50. Once seated in the “hall way” type area just off bar we had to wait another 10 minutes just to get a menu. The charger plates on the table were full of finger prints (do they clean these or just keep putting them on a new table??). Then it was waiting again just to order. Once the server came we ordered everything- drinks apps main course n sides because talking to the people on either side they said it is taking forever. They all left with not even ordering dessert because they were afraid how long it would take to get them. They also had to chase down Rene just get their bill. They were not happy. We finally received r food. Given Brussels sprouts when we never ordered them. Had to send back to get the mashed potatoes. 2 of us had filets that were mealy. It came with these has brown which were cold. The other person had a New York strip which he was happy w. The fries, calamari were very good. The mash potatoes had no flavor. I ate one small piece of the filet n one small piece of the hash browns n left the rest. Never once did the waiter or anyone come around to ask how the meal was. When asked for boxes n I didn’t want one for the basically non eaten filet no questions as to why. We got done r dinner around 10:30. No dessert for us either as no time left. In addition to what was mentioned we had 2 drinks n a glass of wine. That’s it. $311!!! For horrible service, lack of caring on anyone’s part and not great food. I felt horrible for my guests as we had been there 2 years ago n had a great time. Thank god I had comps to pay for it as if I had to this $300 I would have been really pissed off. Won’t b back there for a long time if ever. Save your money n go to the American grill. They seem to b the better place now.
Be the first to ReplyNice dinner.
Dinned here after a show couple of Sunday’s ago. I had the chicken parm and have to say that this could be the best chicken parmigiana in AC and I have tried many at different restaurants. The chicken cooked very nicely, juicy and good flavor and a nice portion. The side of linguini that accompanies the entree is almost like an entree itself. My gf had the sea bass and really enjoyed!! The shrimp scampi was also juicy and flavorful. Being s little pricy but that comes with casino restaurants so it was expected. Love the new bar area they have renovated. Highly recommend and I will be back when in AC!!
Be the first to ReplyExcellence.
Our second visit and it was perfect! Oscar was our server and very accommodating. The food was outstanding! One of my favorites.
Be the first to ReplyExcellent steakhouse
If you are staying at the Borgata and are looking for fine dining, this place is a must. Be sure to get reservations since it filled up fast. Food was excellent (chopped salad and filet were wonderful--french fries not so much). Nice atmosphere, fairly quiet, and nice staff. Som helped guide us to a great pinot noir that paired perfectly with our food. We liked the place so much much didn't want a large meal, so we returned the following night without reservations and sat at the bar, enjoying the chopped salad again (large enough to share), bread, wine, and delicious NY style cheesecake. Our bar waitress was as friendly as the gent we had the night before. Terrific experience. Skip the steakhouse at GN. Atmosphere and attitude doesn't compare to the Old Homestead.
Be the first to ReplyWonderful meal and service.
Delicious. Excellent service- Oscar was the best! Filets cooked to perfection. Sides perfect portion. Have been to several steak houses, this was one of the best.
Be the first to Replywonderful dining
the food was delicious - I had shrimp scampi w/the largest shrimp -there were 6 I could only eat 3. My husband had filet mignon that he said was perfectly done. We shared a crabcake and it was so good - filled with crab. Salad was big enough for 3-4 people. We thought the staff were attentive and very friendly even though they were busy.. Charles was especially pleasant and efficient.
Be the first to ReplyBy far the best steakhouse in AC
This is my second time here and It's the second time that the food and service was outstanding. Lately every steakhouse that I have visited in Ac has been a disappointment but not this place. The steak was cooked to perfection and the sides were great. Definitely a must go.
Be the first to ReplyExcellent Steak
Had a bone in rib eye, excellent, cooked to perfection. HUGE but good. Sat at the bar, had a great cosmo while waiting for dinner. The wedge salad was terrific as well.
Be the first to ReplyBachelor party dinner
Wonderful time food 10/10. Also sever TC was wonderful as well, very on point with service. Been here many times will deff come back as always !!! Shrimp add was my fav!
Be the first to ReplyNYC fine food & dining it's not, except the prices are!
Filet mignon nice flavor but tough for FM, seemed more like a good sirloin. Lobster slightly burnt & not absolutely fresh. Lamb chops were good, not great, but good. Creme Brulee not bad but not worth the calories. The service just seemed to be just "going thru the motions". Noice level loud, overall atmosphere blah.
Be the first to ReplyMy husband's birthday dinner
The food, the ambiance, and service was all amazing. Not only were we in already in a good mood but the experience made it even better.
Be the first to ReplyFABULOUS meal; EXCELLENT service
We took our son here for his 21st birthday. It was a FABULOUS meal! We enjoyed our wagyu steaks. We also really enjoyed the “Meatball” as an appetizer. Service was TOP NOTCH! The server even surprised me by bringing out a dessert with a candle for my son. Will definitely eat here again when at the Borgata.
Be the first to ReplyRibeye to die for!
We were invited to the flyBorgata promotion. (do it if you are offered). While weather was not cooperating with us flying out of Buffalo after a record-setting snowfall, we arrived only about 1-1/2 hours after scheduled arrival. Old Homestead reservation was made well in advance (recommended) for our arrival day - Friday.
Asking the advice of the waiter, who was patient and engaging , recommended the Ribeye. With my order of his recommendation and my wife with the Fillet, we each were delivered a perfect steak. The preparation was spot on! That Ribeye is on my top 5 steak list, and I am no stranger to good beef. We look forward to another trip and visit to Old Homestead.
Oh, and for the wine list, a surprising number of quality selections in the $100-150 range. This was a nice surprise.
Great AC Restaurant
What a great dinner experience we had at this beautiful restaurant. Our visit was on a Saturday night in October and very crowded, so make sure to place reservations. It has two dining levels with a brighter interior design than most steakhouses, we sat on the upper level. From the hostess to the servers, drinks, and food, everything was fantastic. We are trying to dine more in Atlantic City for a change, but Old Homestead has made it hard for us to choose other places. We will return.
Be the first to ReplyAverage server, good food
Not so great to have a condescending server tell you we don't usually split checks. The same server who couldn't remember which customer had which dishes during meal delivery. Food was very good!
Be the first to ReplyWanted a good steak
This place is very nice they have it looking very good it's just very pricey if you're not ready to really spend 300 or more for a couple nice dinner but it's still a nice place to enjoy and have fun
Be the first to ReplyFood and Service Superb
Great Job. Larry and Pam were wonderful. They gave great service with personality. Food delicious but side dishes too big for two people.
Be the first to Reply