Sea Fire Grill New York Tripadvisor Reviews - Sea Fire Grill New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Sea Fire Grill New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Sea Fire Grill New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Sea Fire Grill New York
Sea Fire Grill New York Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
30 Reviews
0 Replys |
New York City's Best!!!
My wife & I always enjoyed this restaurant when we visit New York City. When we arrive, we are always warmly greeted by everyone especially Alex, the General Manager. Our server, Bensen, did a fantastic job explaining every dish to us. He was extremely friendly, helpful and attentive. When it comes to the wine list, Jay, is amazing. He explained some wonderful wines for us to try to complement our seafood and meat entrees. Both of our meals were absolutely delicious! We highly recommend this restaurant and look forward to returning.
Be the first to ReplyWonderful atmosphere, delicious seafood & steak, & spectacular service make for a tremendous dining experience
A genuinely tremendous dining experience. Oysters from both coasts, pan-seared scallops, the house’s “#1 yellowfin,” and the most delicious ribeye I’ve ever tasted. Best of all, the excellent service by our waiter Ori made this night celebrating our daughter’s graduate degree absolutely spectacular
Be the first to ReplyGreat service Sean! Great food chef!
Our first visit last night proved to be amazing! Food and service were excellent. Our waiter Sean, recommended the sea bass and that’s what I choose. It was cooked to perfection and practically melted in your mouth. Also had the seafire salad which was excellent. Maybe the lettuce could have been chopped a bit smaller but it was great. Our service and food were top notch! Hope that one day they can add some nightly specials. It was rather expensive and I think specials could bring in a lot more people. Inside of restaurant was beautiful too!
Be the first to Reply30 th Anniversary
Good was amazing. Service was incredible. Food was tasty and looked amazing. Oysters were wonderful. Great seafood and fish. Great ambience.
Be the first to ReplyGreat place to eat.
Took my love of 35 years out for valentines dinner out in our first adventure to New York. Sea fire grill came highly recommend by our hotel. I must say we were not disappointed. We both had surf and turf which was incredible, wife had salad while I had lobster bisque. Surf and Turf was a thick cut filet Mignon with two healthy lobster tails and the largest jumbo shrimp I’ve ever seen, reminded me of ice landic lobster. Oh and dessert was an amazing New York cheese cake. The entire dinner was an amazing feast. We will visit again.
Be the first to ReplyFirst Time and Definitely Not the Last
This was our first time to Sea Fire Grill. We went out for our wedding anniversary and wanted to try a new restaurant. Our entire experience here was incredible, from the moment we ordered our first drink until we left at the end of the night. The bartender, Ben, lived up to prior reviews we read about him. He was engaging and funny and created a great vibe at the bar. After we moved to our table, Ben continued to serve us both cocktails and our food, which was delicious. Additionally, the level of attention paid to us was unmatched. The entire staff there was attentive to us, good humored and just made the entire night an unforgettable experience. We will definitely be back again.
Be the first to ReplyA Restaurant That Goes Above And Beyond!
I can't speak more highly of Sea Fire! I've visited the restaurant more times than I can count and always multiple times when in town visiting my 94 year-old grandmother. The entire staff are outstanding and treat her like royalty. They know her drink and even what she wants to eat. Even more surprising, the bartenders remember what my partner and I drink, and we only visit twice per year. The staff make a point to come to the table to say hi and check-in. It's also not uncommon for my grandmother to end the night dancing with some people by the bar! At one point, the manager walked my grandmother home to her apartment. Forgive me with names because the entire staff is truly wonderful, but standouts for me are the bartenders Nikki and Ben. This is truly a one-of-a-kind restaurant and that has been proven true every time we visit. And, my God, the food is excellent!!! The surf and turf is by far the best!
Be the first to ReplyRomantic NY Date Place
My husband chose this nice restaurant because I am a seafood person and this looks like a romantic spot for our dinner-date--- it really is! The ambiance is minimalist with refined servers and dark-lit tables. The guests were primarily couple or small adult groups during our visit which was perfect for us who wanted a dinner-date. Food were superb and beautifully designed too-- excellent job chef! The servers, manager were all on top of their game with checking on us and everyone. We will go here once we get the chance to vacation at NYC again-- two thumbs up to all!
Be the first to Replygreat food
food was great, but very cold sittting with the door going open all the time so we hurried tio foinisch our food and get warm again
Be the first to ReplyNice Christmas dinner
We arrived 15 minutes early for our dinner on Christmas Day, thinking we’d have a nice drink before sitting down. When we got to the restaurant, we were, however, met with an incredible mayhem and chaos: the small lobby and bar were absolutely full of people barely being able to move. Talking to some customers, they’d been there a lot longer and had no idea when they’d be seated. It was a terrible start and we were preparing ourselves for the worst ever Christmas dinner. I must say that whatever caused the bottleneck in the early part of the evening was eventually resolved and people got seated and to the credit of the kitchen and waiting staff, the food was delicious and the waiting staff remained reasonably calm. Well done! I deducted one star for the check-in chaos and for the fillet mignons not being quite as perfect as we’ve had them elsewhere before. Altogether a nice meal but with over $600 for for people, I would have expected a little bit more extraordinary dishes. But I guess it was Christmas Day and New York!! Finally, thank you for acknowledging our daughter’s birthday. 😊
Be the first to ReplyStunning restaurant
Had a fabulous night at the Sea fire Grill, service , food , ambience. All terrific. Waiting and bar staff very informative and attentive. All made for a great time . Thank you
Be the first to ReplyJust a wonderful restaurant with great service.
This restaurant is just awesome. It is beautifully appointed and has a great menu. We had swordfish, grilled calamari and clam chowder and finished with cheese cake. We sat at the bar for dinner and Val was beyond terrific as our bartender and server. Great place, great service!!! Highly recommend!!!
Be the first to ReplyFood made the experience better!
Came with small kids on a busy Friday night, the restaurant was accommodating and food was delicious! Only downside after reading other reviews about good service was we had a very unenthusiastic server and host who couldn’t give a *hit, but it’s probably a one-off since all other staff was good!
Be the first to ReplyDiscrimination
It pains me to write this review because I’ve been a long time customer for year’s. I celebrate every major milestone that happens in my life @ Benjamin’s Steakhouse Establishments. Visit on Valentine’s Day with my girlfriend an had a wonderful time up until we decide to have a night cap @ the bar. My girlfriend was hugging an kissing on me to think me for bringing her to sea fire as the atmosphere an food was so good, as she was affection the bartender/waiter (Ben) came over to us a said to us “WE DON’T DO THAT HERE”. This kinda discriminated comment left a BAD taste in my mouth an me an my girlfriend looking very confused. There was a lot of couples in that establishment doing the same thing we was doing he never said anything to them. We was discriminated against because we was 2 females an found his comment unnecessary. To this day my girlfriend bring the bartender comments up because she couldn’t make sense of it an why the comment was made. This hurt me to my soul because my personal lifestyle has never been commented on @ any place I’ve visited with my companion
Be the first to ReplyElegant and sophisticated east sider serves delicious food with gracious service
This was our first time at Sea Fire Grill even though we live 4 blocks away. Occupying the space that used to be Chiam, Sea Fare Grill is a winner in every respect. Welcoming and gracious staff serve a sophisticated cuisine in a refined and elegant space. Even though one expects that seafood would reign, the filet mignon we had was one of the best in memory: tender, juicy, flavorful and cooked to perfection. The lobster bisque was velvety and luscious. There is an extensive wine list for every taste; we had an excellent dry Chardonnay from Navarra which complemented ideally our seafood appetizer and meat main course. The rich cheesecake and flavorful lemon sorbet we shared after dinner were the perfect choice and were followed by espresso. All in all, a delightful dining experience. Highly recommended.
Be the first to ReplyMATCHLESS FOOD AND SERVICE. !!
omg.! I am a long Islander who spent the holiday at my vacation club in NYC. About The Sea Fire Grill? I have not experience great tasty food and service like this place! The food was just outstanding! The best crab cake I have ever experienced. and it was an experience indeed. I have dined at some very good restaurants but When you experience food that you just cannot forget!? I am not a beef eater, my friend is she ordered the filet mignon and so I tasted a bit of hers and OMG! Tender like butter and the taste outstanding. Complementary eggnog with a touch of rum was delicious! . Our waiter was amazing and the atmosphere elegant yet comfortable. I am a Juniors cheesecake fan and swore by no other but! The cheese cake here is a challenge for Juniors ! I look forward to going back here again soon. My compliments to the fine CHEF!
Be the first to ReplyGreat food
We had originally had reservations for 8 pm on a Saturday night, we asked to be seated earlier and we were able to get seated at 6 pm instead. The service was good and the food was wonderful. I had a New England Clam Chowder that was fantastic (one of the best I have ever had). The Risling by the glass was very good. Everything we ordered was very good. I can understand why this restaurant generally gets great reviews. By the time we were finished with dinner, the restaurant was completely full and the reception area was packed. If we had kept our original reservation time, I don't think we would have been seated on time. I agree with previous reviews, the prices are quite dear but the food is good.
Be the first to ReplyEast Side Gem for great dining experience
Outstanding fixed price lunch with first class food, service and ambiance. We happened to be on the East Side and selected this restaurant because of menu and ratings. Not to disappoint. Service was exceptional and everyone was so friendly. Food could not be better - we had fish entrees. I am sorry I do not live nearby as this would be our go to place!
Be the first to ReplyNice place
Very welcoming staff. We went early without reservations for half price oysters and champagne, then had dinner in the bar. Food was very good. My friend had pasta which she enjoyed, I had branzino and that was delicious. Turned out to be expensive meal but we enjoyed. Would certainly return.
Be the first to ReplyThanksgiving dinner with very little to be thankful for
We came for thanksgiving dinner from the glowing reviews and were very disappointed. Firstly having had to wait for 20 minutes for our table with no apology for the delay, the rest just got worse. It was like we were being rushed in and our without being to enjoy the food or wine. The food was rushed, one course after the other with little time in between. You get no better sense to leave than being given the bill as dessert is coming out. Almost done, I decide to use the bathroom and the waiter tries to take away the wine I had left. The food quality wasn’t great either, the starters of Rockefeller oysters were nice but then turkey tasted processed and something which may have come from a tin and put in the microwave. Definitely will not be coming back
Be the first to Reply5 stars for food and service
I have always wanted to eat at Sea Fire Grill based on the reviews and everything I dreamed about came true. The restaurant itself is beautiful and you walk into a lovely greeting. I cannot say enough about how good the food and service was and how I will be back for one more visit before we leave NYC. Oh, and if you do go, make sure you have the cheesecake.
Be the first to ReplyGreat food, service and ambiance
Our first time at Sea Fire Grill was exceptional. We sat at the bar first and had oysters and delicious cocktails made by Ben. Then we sat down and had a terrific dinner. It was restaurant week so we took advantage of the menu, it was a great value. The octopus, lobster bisque and the squid ink pasta with the lobster were outstanding. Our server Diar was truly accommodating. We couldn’t have asked for a better evening.
Be the first to ReplyDisappointing experience despite the quality of the food.
I tried this place prior to Covid and rated it highly, returned this week, Tuesday, as I was staying a couple of doors up. Whilst the food especially the squid starter was excellent but the overall meal spoilt by a very loud crowd waiting for their table. Considerate of other diners they were not. Obviously the restaurant is rated highly given how busy they were but perhaps they should consider asking those patrons who can't act like responsible grown ups to modify their noise.
Be the first to ReplyGreat food!
The food here was great, very lively atmosphere, excellent service! Definitely make a reservation, this place is busy!
Be the first to ReplyAllergy
Despite booking the restaurant requesting the food to go easy on salt + acknowledging our server who was aware of my request The fish was served with excessive seasoning . The management did not apologise or acknowledge such a simple request There are better seafood restaurants in NyC
Be the first to Reply